WHY CHOOSE NUTMARE?
Not all peanut butter and jam are created equal. Every Nutmare product is crafted in small batches using real ingredients, bold flavors, and a passion for creating something unforgettable.
🥜 REAL INGREDIENTS
Fresh peanuts, real fruit, local honey, and simple ingredients you can recognize.
👻 SMALL BATCH CRAFTED
Made in small batches for quality and consistency—not mass-produced in giant factories.
🌽 MADE IN IOWA
Proudly handcrafted in Iowa and inspired by the Midwest.
🚫 NO PRESERVATIVES
No unnecessary preservatives. Just real food and real flavor.
🎃 unique FLAVORS
From Iowa’s Haunting and Devil’s Fiddle to Vampire’s Kiss and Blackberry Midnight.
❤️ FAMILY OWNED
Every purchase supports a local family business chasing a dream.
Ready to taste the Nightmare?
HERE'S WHAT customers are saying
THE FLAVORS
Nutmare
Iowa's Haunting
The Origin: Before the monsters, before the madness, there was the original. Nutmare Original was created to prove that simple ingredients can still create something unforgettable. Fresh peanuts, a touch of salt, and nothing to hide behind.
Nutmare Warning: Many customers buy this as a “safe choice.” They usually return for more flavors.
The Origin: I wanted a flavor that represented home. Using locally sourced Iowa honey, I created a peanut butter that captures the sweetness of the Midwest while staying true to Nutmare’s dark roots. It’s proof that even Iowa has a few sweet secrets hiding in the shadows.
Nutmare Warning: Strange sightings of empty jars have been reported throughout Iowa.
8oz: $8.00
16oz: $12.00
8oz: $10.00
16oz: $13.99
The Golden Harvest
Devil's Fiddle
The Origin: I wanted to create a peanut butter that felt rich, smooth, and a little special. After discovering acacia honey—one of the sweetest honeys in the world—I knew it deserved its own flavor. Golden Harvest combines fresh peanuts and golden honey into a jar worthy of a king’s table.
Nutmare Warning: May cause customers to stare into the jar searching for hidden treasure.
The Origin: Most spicy peanut butters just bring heat. I wanted something smoky, sweet, and sinister that slowly creeps up on you.
Nutmare Warning: If your ears start smoking, that’s normal.
8oz: $10.00
16oz: $13.99
8oz: $10.00
16oz: $13.99
Spooky Cookie
The Origin: One night I wanted something different from the usual chocolate and honey flavors. I started thinking about those late-night cookie cravings, so I blended the taste of sweet cookies into fresh peanut butter. The result was Spooky Cookie—a flavor that tastes like a haunted bakery after dark.
Nutmare Warning: Do not leave unattended near milk. The cookies may start calling your name.
8oz: $11.99
16oz: $15.99
Ghostly Chill
The Origin: I wanted a flavor that felt like a haunted ice cream shop at midnight. Mint and chocolate seemed like the perfect combination for a chilling Nutmare experience.
Nutmare Warning: Side effects may include freezing in place while staring into the jar.
8oz: $11.99
16oz: $15.99
Batter Splatter
The Origin: I’ve been obsessed with brownies since I was a kid. While creating new Nutmare flavors, I wanted something that tasted like licking brownie batter straight from the bowl. After a lot of testing, Batter Splatter was born.
Nutmare Warning: May result in customers hiding jars from family members.
8oz: $11.99
16oz: $15.99
JELLYMARE COLLECTION
Vampire's kiss
Legend says a lonely vampire wandered the Nutmare graveyard searching for something sweeter than blood. Raspberry obsession.
8oz: $8.00 | 16oz: $12.00
Love at first bite
One stormy evening, Nutmare crossed paths with Jellymare. That sweet moment when fate brought two souls together.
8oz: $8.00 | 16oz: $12.00
blackberry midnight
Deep within the cemetery, Jellymare gathered blackberries beneath the moonlight. Crafted for mystery seekers.
8oz: $8.00 | 16oz: $12.00
phantom vine
A phantom spirit wandered forgotten vineyards. Jellymare transformed the harvest into a grape ghost.
8oz: $8.00 | 16oz: $12.00
Camp Dread
A smoky, pine-infused strawberry jelly that tastes like a campfire story gone terribly wrong.
8oz: $12.99 | 16oz: $13.99
Scream-Sicle
Violent orange and creamy vanilla spreadable panic. Inspired by chilling summer festival nights.
8oz: $12.99 | 16oz: $13.99
Ghoulish Glaze
Eerie green apple with a hint of cinnamon spirits. It's the harvest flavor that refuses to stay buried.
8oz: $12.99 | 16oz: $13.99
Strawberry Hex
Dark, crushed strawberries cursed with obsidian spices once used to summon high-quality snacks.
8oz: $12.99 | 16oz: $13.99
Get in Touch with the Nightmare
Have a burning question about our haunting flavors, organic ingredients, or shipping mysteries? Interested in custom orders for your next big event? Fill out the form below and our team will get back to you before the next full moon.
Meet the Creator
Hi, I’m Bodhi, the owner and creator of Nutmare. Every jar you see is something I’ve spent countless hours creating, testing, and perfecting. From roasting peanuts to making small-batch jams, my goal has never been to create just another peanut butter or jam company. I wanted to build a brand with personality, creativity, and a little bit of horror. Nutmare started with a simple idea: make products that people actually remember. Whether it’s our classic spreads or our upcoming spooky jam flavors like Camp Dread, Strawberry Hex, Scream-Sicle, and Ghoulish Glaze, I want every jar to feel like part of a bigger story. Right now, I’m still a small business owner making products one batch at a time. Every order, every follow, every share, and every kind comment helps me get one step closer to my dream. My vision doesn’t stop with peanut butter and jam. One day I hope Nutmare grows into something much bigger—a place known for creative flavors, unforgettable stories, and a community that enjoys trying something different. This is only Chapter One. Thank you to everyone who’s supported me so far. I can’t wait to show you what’s coming next. Welcome to Nutmare.